Valter H. Must, Esq.

Nearby Lawyers New Jersey Ocean County Toms River Toms River Robbins Street

(7 reviews)

Contact Info

Location 9 Robbins St, Toms River, NJ 08753, USA
Phone +1 732-797-1600
Website http://www.cldds.com/

Reviews

I agree with the other 3 existing reviews, this man is a terrible judge (and I know what I am taking about, as I am a very experienced litigant). I had the displeasure of appearing at a motion hearing before this judge for the first time on Oct 20, 2023 via Zoom. It was clear that he did not read the motion papers at all (i.e. neither my opposition, nor even defense counsel's moving papers). He was completely unaware of the basis for the motion, which defense counsel had to spoon feed to this judge during oral argument. He then not only refused to let me explain the basis for my opposition before jumping to the incorrect conclusion (i.e he cut me off after only the first 2 sentences out of my mouth), he further was completely unprofessional in how he spoke to me. That is, he mocked the little bit that I was allowed to say, and then insulted me. When I tried to explain further, he told me to "shut up". Never in over 3 decades of my courtroom experiences (i.e. over 3 dozen cases and literally hundreds of court proceedings), has any other judge spoken to me in such an unprofessional manner. Then when I tried to explain the hardship that his unfair ruling would cause me, he again cut me off and callously refused to even hear what I had to say. Other reviewers have said that they had intended to file a complaint against this judge. I don't know if they ever went through with it or not, but based on my past experiences with the ACJC, they probably won't do anything unless and until dozens and dzens of more litigants come forward and file their complaints, as I intend to do now.
Partial judge. I am surprised that in the 21st century he is allowed in the courts. Very narcistic with no conscience. He seemed to have a significant relationship with a female lawyer. I think further inquiries about his behaviors are indicated at this time. He doesn't bother looking at any evidence. His involvement with this female lawyer was enough to make a decision at the start of the case. I am sure that if his actions would be investigated, as they should be, it would cause many to loose faith in the court system in Ocean County NJ. A newspaper editor reached out to me, as she heard about my case. (I assumed other cases with this judge as well, but I am not sure.) I think she may have something to unravel.
Partial judge. I am surprised that in the 21st century he is allowed in the courts. Very narcistic with no conscience. He seemed to have a significant relationship with a female lawyer. I think further inquiries about his behaviors are indicated at this time. He doesn't bother looking at any evidence. His involvement with this female lawyer was enough to make a decision at the start of the case. I am sure that if his actions would be investigated, as they should be, it would cause many to loose faith in the court system in Ocean County NJ. A newspaper editor reached out to me, as she heard about my case. (I assumed other cases with this judge as well, but I am not sure.) I think she may have something to unravel.
If I could I’d give negative stars. I completely agree with all of the reviewers. He doesn’t read facts or information or anything you give him. He’s lazy, incompetent, very pretentious and has no problem ruining someone’s life and mental health cause of it. I would love for him to be removed from that high horse he thinks he belongs on and get back down where he belongs, perhaps he could use some type of educational counseling to learn how to deal with family law. I’m sure I’m not the only person that was treated unfairly and can honestly say there is no fair justice or understanding to any situation. He just wants to clear his calendar and screw over the next contestant on the @“&$ show he entertains. Yea nj is not a father state but us fathers do need to pay and shut up as we fall in line for what seems like child support being more of a business. Call child support’s number ask yourself why are the defendants or people who pay referred to as customers? I’d say to all judges “don’t judge lest ye be judged yourself”!!!
If I could I’d give negative stars. I completely agree with all of the reviewers. He doesn’t read facts or information or anything you give him. He’s lazy, incompetent, very pretentious and has no problem ruining someone’s life and mental health cause of it. I would love for him to be removed from that high horse he thinks he belongs on and get back down where he belongs, perhaps he could use some type of educational counseling to learn how to deal with family law. I’m sure I’m not the only person that was treated unfairly and can honestly say there is no fair justice or understanding to any situation. He just wants to clear his calendar and screw over the next contestant on the @“&$ show he entertains. Yea nj is not a father state but us fathers do need to pay and shut up as we fall in line for what seems like child support being more of a business. Call child support’s number ask yourself why are the defendants or people who pay referred to as customers? I’d say to all judges “don’t judge lest ye be judged yourself”!!!
This attorney has been made a judge In Ocean County family division nobody with his temperament and lack of discretion should be made a judge. I will be filing a complaint against him. I would not be surprised if I’m not the only one . On the record he compard me to another litigant from another case completely inappropriate and has a predisposed hatred to anybody wanting to represent themselves.
This attorney has been made a judge In Ocean County family division nobody with his temperament and lack of discretion should be made a judge. I will be filing a complaint against him. I would not be surprised if I’m not the only one . On the record he compard me to another litigant from another case completely inappropriate and has a predisposed hatred to anybody wanting to represent themselves.
Refuses to follow state guidelines and makes up his own biased rules and then threatens you if you seek justice for unfairness. This judge only favors women even if they are the guilty party. If you are a man, change your venue. You WILL NOT have a fair court room.

Contact Us

About Valter H. Must, Esq.

Navigating the legal system can often be complex and challenging, and selecting the right legal professional is a critical step for anyone in New Jersey facing a legal matter. The relationship between a client and their legal representative, or even a judge overseeing their case, is built on trust, respect, and the expectation of fair and knowledgeable guidance. For residents in the New Jersey area, understanding what to look for and what to be aware of when seeking legal counsel or appearing in court is paramount.

This article aims to provide a clear and informative overview of considerations when engaging with legal professionals, specifically referencing Valter H. Must, Esq., whose public feedback as a judge raises significant points for the community. While we do not invent information, we will base our discussion on available public data to help New Jersey users learn more about experiences shared by others and consider these aspects when making their own legal decisions. Our goal is to offer factual insights to empower individuals in their search for professional and equitable legal assistance.

Valter H. Must, Esq.'s office is located at 9 Robbins St, Toms River, NJ 08753, USA. This address places the office within Toms River, a central location in Ocean County, New Jersey. For local residents, the accessibility of a legal office is often a key factor in choosing representation. Toms River is a well-known hub, and the office's position within the town likely offers various ways for clients to reach it.

Whether traveling by personal vehicle from surrounding communities like Brick, Lakewood, or Lacey, the location is generally considered to be within reasonable driving distance for many in the region. Parking availability in the vicinity of 9 Robbins St would be a practical consideration for those driving. For individuals relying on public transportation within Toms River or connecting from other parts of Ocean County, it would be advisable to consult local bus routes and schedules for the most up-to-date information on stops near this address. The general ease of access to a central Toms River location like this allows for convenient scheduling of appointments for New Jersey residents seeking legal services.

Based on the provided public reviews, the information regarding specific services offered by Valter H. Must, Esq., as an attorney is not available. The reviews primarily focus on his conduct and performance in a judicial capacity, rather than detailing services provided as a practicing lawyer. Therefore, we cannot list specific attorney services.

However, the reviews do highlight aspects of a judicial role that are critical for any legal professional, whether a judge or an attorney, in the New Jersey legal system:

Understanding of Legal Documentation: Reviewers indicate a concern regarding the reading and comprehension of legal motion papers. This suggests that in any legal capacity, a thorough understanding of submitted documents is crucial for effective decision-making or advocacy.
Fair Hearing and Opportunity to Speak: The importance of allowing all parties to fully present their case and explain their position is emphasized. This highlights the need for any legal professional to ensure due process and provide an equitable platform for communication.
Professional Demeanor and Respectful Communication: The reviews point to significant issues with professional conduct and communication in a courtroom setting. This underscores the necessity for all legal professionals to maintain a respectful, unbiased, and professional demeanor, regardless of their role.
Impartiality and Unbiased Decision-Making: Concerns about partiality and potential relationships influencing decisions are raised. This stresses the fundamental requirement for judges and attorneys alike to remain impartial, base decisions solely on evidence, and avoid any appearance of conflicts of interest to maintain public trust in the legal system.

It is important for potential clients seeking legal services in New Jersey to consider these general principles of professionalism, knowledge, and impartiality when evaluating any legal representative.

The provided public reviews offer significant insights into experiences with Valter H. Must, Esq., particularly in a judicial role. These reviews highlight several critical points that can serve as "features" or "highlights" from the perspective of public feedback, albeit concerning his performance as a judge rather than his specific attorney services.

Concerns Regarding Judicial Preparedness: Multiple reviews indicate a perceived lack of preparedness, specifically regarding the reading of motion papers prior to hearings. This suggests an issue with a judge's foundational readiness to preside over cases, which is a critical aspect of judicial duty.
Issues with Professional Demeanor: Reviewers describe instances of unprofessional conduct, including mocking, insulting, and telling a litigant to "shut up." This raises concerns about maintaining decorum and respect in the courtroom, which are essential for a fair legal environment.
Allegations of Partiality and Bias: Strong accusations of partiality, particularly concerning a "significant relationship with a female lawyer" influencing decisions, are made. This directly challenges the impartiality and fairness expected of a judge, which are fundamental pillars of justice.
Limited Opportunity for Litigant Explanation: Reviewers state that they were cut off and not allowed to fully explain their position or the hardship caused by rulings. This suggests a potential disregard for due process and the right of parties to be heard.
Impact on Public Trust: Comments about actions potentially causing many to "lose faith in the court system in Ocean County NJ" underscore the profound effect that judicial conduct can have on public perception and trust in the legal system.
Intent to File Complaints: The mention of intentions to file complaints with the Advisory Committee on Judicial Conduct (ACJC) by multiple litigants highlights the severity of the perceived issues and the formal steps individuals are considering to address them.

These observations from public reviews, while specific to a judicial context, emphasize the importance of thoroughness, professionalism, impartiality, and respect as critical qualities for any legal professional serving the New Jersey community.

Based on the publicly available information provided, there are no specific promotions or special offers advertised for Valter H. Must, Esq. As the reviews primarily focus on his conduct as a judge, rather than his practice as an attorney, typical promotional content for legal services is not present.

For general inquiries about legal services or to understand potential fee structures for any legal professional, it is always recommended for individuals in New Jersey to contact the office directly. This allows for a direct conversation about your specific legal needs and any related costs.

To connect with the office at this location, please use the following contact information:

Address: 9 Robbins St, Toms River, NJ 08753, USA

Phone: (732) 797-1600

Mobile Phone: +1 732-797-1600

These contact details provide the means to reach the office directly for any inquiries or to schedule a consultation.

For residents of New Jersey, particularly those in Toms River and the surrounding areas, selecting a legal professional is a decision that requires careful consideration. While the provided reviews for Valter H. Must, Esq. primarily reflect experiences in a judicial capacity and raise significant concerns about judicial conduct, they underscore universal principles critical to effective and ethical legal representation.

The feedback highlights the paramount importance of a legal professional—whether an attorney or a judge—being prepared, demonstrating impartiality, maintaining professional communication, and allowing all parties to be fully heard. These are foundational elements of a fair and just legal process. When seeking an attorney in New Jersey, locals should prioritize professionals who are known for their thoroughness, ethical conduct, respectful engagement, and commitment to unbiased advocacy. The location in Toms River offers geographic convenience for many in Ocean County. However, the experiences shared in the public reviews serve as a crucial reminder for all New Jersey residents to conduct due diligence, review available feedback, and prioritize legal professionals who exemplify the highest standards of integrity and service to ensure trust in the legal system remains strong. It is imperative that individuals feel confident their chosen legal representative will act with professionalism, knowledge, and an unwavering commitment to justice.